Kishi (Reporters) Clubs System - Japan's Press System

Japan, one of the few developed nations in Asiaeditorial page of Wall Street Journal.
and the world's second largest economy isWhen compared with the press in other leading
considered a liberal democracy with aindustrial countries in the world, Japan is so
constitutional monarchy type of government andremarkably different in media. This is primarily due
citizens maintain all their civil rights.to the deluging control of the Liberal Democratic
It is run under a one-party rule, the LiberalParty over the mainstream media with the Kisha
Democratic Party (LDP). No real challenge to theclubs system as its mouthpiece.
LDP was able to sustain itself despite theThe first three decades of the 20th century, the
decrease in its popularity since the economicpress was controlled through self-censorship.
inactivity in l990s and corruption scandals.Obnoxious events, no matter how significant
For decades, Japan has not experience a changereceived no attention if they could adversely
in political administration. Japan is a democracyaffect the interest of the ruling party. The
without a competition. One may wonder how thisdevelopment of communist party was also a
could be possible when democracy is founded onforbidden subject.
competition. A Tokyo-based political analyst,Access to information of Japan's mainstream
Minoru Morita said that for a long period of time,media is under the monopoly of the ill-refute Kisha
the major media have been serving at the LDP's(reporters) club systems. These clubs are
discretion. And that is one of the secrets of itsattached to the government's major institutions
long-term rule.including the police. Foreign press, freelance
The condition of the Japanese press seems to be,journalists and magazines find it difficult to get
at first sight, analog to that established in theaccess to important information. However, there
West. There are major daily newspapers withwere significant scandals uncovered by journalists
huge bulk of people reading at least oneworking outside the system despite difficulties.
newspaper every day. The degree of reporting isThere was a sharp contrast between the reports
adept. Dissemination of news is vigorous not onlyof the outside press and those of the major
through newspapers but also the television andnewspapers. The major newspapers reported
the internet.differently from those covered and reported by
There are only five national newspaper whichJapanese magazines. The major papers allowed
accounts for half of the country's total circulation,themselves to be manipulated by the ruling LDP.
Asahi Shim bun, the Mainichi Shimbun, Nihon KeizaiJapanese press does not lead but follow. This is
Shimbun, Sankei Shimbun and the Yomiurione of the most serious issues in Japanese
Shimbun.journalism - failure to keep those in power
A scrutiny of the contents, however, reveals aaccountable. They cover the scandal only after it
uniformity of editorial style among thesehas already been uncovered.
newspapers. It is hard if not impossible toJapan's press system lacks independence. Its
characterize one or another as representing amanipulation of the press does not only weaken
specific political attitude as one can find in Newdemocracy but also subverts press freedom
York Times' liberal standpoint and in conservativeglobally.