Imagining 'The Good Society' Part Two

As part of the struggle for 'The Good Society', itcalled upon to mediate.
is necessary to aim for the right economic,Employees of the state involved in the provision
political and social mix.of social services and welfare might develop an
In pursuit of this, one response is the pursuit of ainterest in the continuation or improvement of
'democratic mixed economy': an economicservices in their field. Teachers, for instance, have
template which pursues economic democracy,not only been involved in struggles for wage
strategic planning and public ownership, and thejustice: they have been at the heart of struggles
harnessing of market forces.for a more progressive curriculum.
Already we have considered this in 'part one' ofAnd it is not unimaginable to suppose that some
this series.police - who themselves have experienced
The "Good Society", however, is more than aindustrial struggles - might under some
question of how best to manage the economy.circumstances be reluctant to break the picket
Underlining Australian democracy - andlines of other workers.
democracies the world over - is a presumedFurthermore, strategies of "dual power" may
social contract of liberal democratic consensus.involve the creation of alternative democratic
The maintenance of social compromise, here, isinstitutions - community media, mutual and building
critical. To begin with, such a compromise cansocieties, non-exploitative co-operative enterprise
provide the framework for cultural and political- beyond the internal contradictions of the State
pluralism: essential for modern multiculturalPower.
societies.A more radical example might involve the
However, the rationale for social compromiseestablishment of "community development" or
goes deeper still:"citizens investment" funds from below - through
All social actors have a shared interest in avoidingindustrial action.
a "vacuum" which can be filled by a desperate and"The Good Society", here, is one which is open to
brutal struggle to re-impose a social order.change: through the dynamic of class struggle, as
Such scenarios developed during the 1789-1799well as the struggles by minorities and interest
Revolution in France, and also following the 1917groups for recognition, and socio-economic justice.
Russian Revolution. After the experience of theBut such a society is also one whose liberal
Jacobins in France, the desperate efforts offoundations allow for civil disobedience, while acting
revolutionary governments to hold power hasas a bulwark against the disintegration of social
been termed as "Jacobinism".order, violent desperation: even Terror.
Whatever the ideals of the revolutionaries in suchIn conclusion, "The Good Society" is one marked
struggles, ordinary people in their hundreds ofby a liberal and social democratic consensus. It is a
thousands perished in the Terror and the warssociety characterised by a "mixed democratic
which ensued.economy" whose aim it is to provide for the
Of course, counter-revolutionary Terror can becomplex tapestry of human need.
just as horrible or worse than revolutionarySo complex a tapestry refers to material, social
Terror. But surely, if there is an alternative - andand cultural need; and to spiritual and secular
less brutal - road to change, then we should use it.aspiration for hope, kindness, justice, love, peace
So, in avoiding such Terror, the social compromiseand meaning. The "Good Society" aims for a
of liberal democracy commands our attention andmarket which is democratic, innovative,
respect.responsive, fair and participatory. Such a social
The composition of any "liberal democraticproject aims beyond the crude logic of share
consensus" or "social compromise", however, isvalue maximisation.
strongly contested.The Good Society", by this reckoning, is one
Without social rights and social democracy, such awhere each contributes according to their ability,
consensus is simply not enough. The liberaland each receives according to their need.
democratic consensus underlining the UnitedThe stability and endurance of liberal and social
States, for instance, is not necessarily a comfortdemocratic consensus and compromise is also
to its poor and vulnerable, including thecentral to the pursuit of a good and just social
unemployed, the exploited and the homeless.order.
And sometimes - such as with the outbreak ofHere, the best defence for liberal, democratic and
World War in 1914 - the acquiescence of electedsocial rights is a culture of civic mobilisation and
governments in the face of such barbarism andactivism, and of critical inquiry.
horror - shatters any illusion or semblance ofReference to a culture of "civic mobilisation"
legitimacy.includes the strength of NGOs (Non-Government
Ultimately, even where a democratic governmentOrganisations), social movements, religious
carries a mandate, pursuit of justice demandsorganisations and movements, trade unions, and
that workers, citizens, minorities - engage inpolitical parties.
struggle for their liberal and social rights. (and in"Civic mobilisation" also refers to the capacity of
the case of unjust wars - for diplomacy andsuch organisations and movements to build
peace)counter-hegemonic strategies to challenge the
Liberal democratic compromise might ensure thesocial order, and - where appropriate - to take
right of citizens and workers to mobilise and arguecollective action - including civil disobedience.
in the "public sphere", and to exercise the right ofSuch a culture is best sustained through a robust
universal suffrage.and participatory "public sphere": in participatory
But there are instances, also, when people needelectronic media, journals and newspapers, public
to push the limits of liberal democratic socialassemblies and social forums.
compromise. Strategies of civil disobedience: rallies,The foundations of "active/critical" citizenship,
occupations, political strike action, the holding ofhere, are best laid early: in the process of public
picket lines - can well be justified.education, and in the development of curricula and
And while Terror and brutalisation must beteaching strategies. The emphasis, here, ought be
avoided, strategies of civil disobedience can leadupon value formation, ideological literacy, civic
to physical confrontation between ordinary peoplemobilisation (including public sphere participation),
and the state power.and critical appreciation of issues through
Such circumstances can comprise a delicateengagement in the Humanities and Social Sciences.
"balancing out": one where physical confrontationHopefully this task of imagining of just what
and conflict is limited by mutual restraint. Failure toconstitutes the "Good Society" might compromise
exercise restraint, though, can result in a crisis ofa starting point for real efforts to improve the
legitimacy, descent into repression, and escalation.world.
Under circumstances of liberal democraticAfter all, the "point" is not just to talk about the
consensus, the state itself - to an extent - alsoworld but to change it.
comes to embody the social contradictions it is