Hometown Democracy - A Bad Idea With a Feel Good Name

Florida's statewide growth management lawgrowth requiring a change to the Comprehensive
requires input from professional planners, twoPlan. Developers could have no confidence that a
public hearings, a review and an appeals processwell conceived and desirable project would be
at the state level and numerous opportunities forapproved by voters. If such intelligent growth is
citizens to participate in and challenge any changesstifled, builders will take the path of least
to the Comprehensive Plan. Passage of theresistance by creating the urban sprawl already
Hometown Democracy amendment would replaceallowed under current land use regulations.
this comprehensive process with ballot boxOne of the arguments put forth by Hometown
planning.Democracy proponents is that our elected officials
Each and every change to the Comprehensivehave let us down. I disagree with this, but let's
Plan, no matter how minor, would require a vote.assume it's true. These officials were elected by
Reportedly, there was a yearly average of overthe same voters who would make the growth
10,000 plan changes in Florida over the past fourmanagement decisions. If you believe that we
years. Broward County would have requiredcan't elect competent officials, how can you
votes on 686 items per year.believe that we would make great planners?
Comprehensive Plans are living documents,Who would pay for the voting? We, the
requiring modifications as situations change. Theytaxpayers would pay. Who would most likely win
often come into play when property is annexedin any contested decision? Probably the side with
and when new roads or schools are planned. Theythe biggest advertising budget. Our forefathers
allow planners to intelligently create things likecreated a Representative Republic, not a
planned communities. In most of rural Flaglerdemocracy, because they could foresee the
County current planning regulations allow for onlyresulting chaos of a pure democracy.
one residential unit for each five acres, promotingDo not be fooled. Do not sign their petition. The
urban sprawl. ANY change to this, such asFlorida Legislature recently enacted tough laws to
approval for a planned community, with clusteredmore carefully manage growth by ensuring that
housing, green space, and amenities would requireroads and schools are in place to meet the needs
a vote.of growth - before new developments can be
The extended time delay for approval, the addedbuilt. We should give these laws a chance to work
cost to "sell" a project and the uncertainty ofbefore resorting to extreme measures.
outcome will combine to essentially stop any