Elections by Random Lottery? A Polemic for "Sortition"

In a true democracy where the Parliament truly"It had judicial functions in addition to being, as
(that is, in a "statistically correct" manner)representative of the periodic assembly of all
represents the people, shouldn't the elections becitizens, generally responsible for the fiscal
carried out by random lottery?well-being of Athens," Callenbach and Phillips
Isn't that the way mathematicians draw a correctcontinue.
sample from any statistical "population"? Isn't that"The boule system prevailed for about as long as
the way juries are selected in American courtsthe American republic has, and lost its power only
(although I am aware of the mind-bendingthrough the growth of a class of specialized
machinations that lurk below the orderly surfaceofficials serving long terms: in modern parlance, a
of the jury-selection process).bureaucracy." [There I disagree since I believe
As a matter of fact, once upon a time, aboutwith Max Weber that a bureaucracy is actually a
2,500 years ago, that's how elections weremanifestation of increasing rationalization of routine
carried out in ancient Greece. Everybody could notprocesses in a complex market economy,
vote, that's one technical detail we have toalthough the form itself has been abused and
disclose obviously. But those who were eligible totransmortified (I'm afraid I've just made up that
vote were represented correctly throughword) beyond recognition.]
"random elections" called "sortition.""Just as the Athenian boule existed in conjunction
In ancient Greece the "boule" or the governingwith the citizen assembly, we may imagine a new
council had 500 members chosen by lottery fromdirect- representation house of Congress existing
the ten "tribes" of Athens to serve one-yearin conjunction with a Senate chosen by traditional
terms, according to Ernest Callenbach &electoral means. The new body we propose to
Michael Phillips of the Context Institute. A lot ofcall the Representative House."
members for a tiny city state, I'd think. But theyWill it happen anytime soon in any country around
served for only one year, so that's okay in mythe world? Of course not. But is it worth thinking
book.about? I certainly think so.