Crisis in Kyrgyzstan - What Does This Humanitarian Disaster Mean For the USA?

It is often amazing how events around the globeopposition leaders for seeking for standing up to
affect us here at home. Sometimes it pays to doan authoritarian regime however. A planned, well
nothing, and at other times we cannot turn athought out Coup d'état can actually be a very
blind's eye. How we handle such affairs says a lotsound and efficient instrument in bringing about
about who we are, what we stand for, and ourchange and has done so for many countries.
primary focus and objectives in those areas ofHowever this debacle was far from an organized
the world; the US cannot be all things to all people.military move, it was a knee jerk reaction that
Sometimes it may seem cruel to do nothing, butresulted in dozens of deaths and has left the
often that is the best course of action, even if itpeople without a leader and a crippled
hurts our hearts to watch things unfold.infrastructure. Matters could even be made worse
The Kyrgyzstan Revolution and civil unrest is halfby opposition leaders if they are incompetent
a world away, but it still affects us here in theenough to begin a power struggle amongst
United States. Not long ago, I was discussing thisthemselves for leadership positions within the new
Geo-Political issue with a post cold war scholar onparty. In fighting and division right now would only
Russian-US Relations, and I asked Mr. Jessedelay the chaos and looting that is taking place in
Giraldo point blank; What do you think about thetheir own streets further destabilizing and
latest challenges in Kyrgyzstan, that does throw adestroying their economic infrastructure.
loop in the fire? Here is his reply;In my analysis this party has only two realistic
Where to start. Well It's certainly made thingschoices, they can continue to attempt an effort
quite a bit more complicated. Kyrgyzstan hasat establishing a new government under their
been the geopolitical battleground for competingadministration or they can reach out to Russia for
military intrests between the U.S and the Russiansassistance in re-establishing order in the region.
since the 90's. Kyrgyzstan has been politicallyHowever the latter may be a pipe dream since
unstable since the tulip revolt but now things haveMoscow will be hesitant to send troops in to quell
descended from bad to worse. At least beforethe violence as they are already under suspicion
Bakiyev had a functioning albeit authoritarianof inciting the violence against Bakiyevs
government that was capable of running thegovernment by a number of groups including
countries affairs, what's happening in Kyrgyzstanmost notably Uzbekistan. And Russia doesn't
now is nothing short of mob rule anarchy.seem to feel it's worth it to jeopardize relations
Kyrgyzstan is experiencing the pent up frustrationwith its valued natural gas supplier. Bottom line it's
of over 5 years of bureaucratic abuse at thea madhouse and the country is in a state of free
hands of its own government. This is Bakiyev'sfall while the U.S and Russia are keeping a safe
just deserts for implementing authoritariandistance but still watching very intently.
doctrines while failing to weed out the corruptionAll great points made by Jesse Giraldo, and so I
he claimed to stand against. In the end he wasasked some more questions, namely; "Do you
little better than his predecessor and like so manythink that many of those in Kyrgyzstan look
he ended up becoming the very thing he foughtdown on the US for their ties with the fallen
to destroy. He drove his own people to the brinkgovernment, as we made deals with them to
of poverty with ridiculous tax hikes and laws andallow a base there for aerial logistics? Or do you
now people are dying.believe that suspicion will blow over, as we didn't
The real tragedy of the whole crisis isn't evenstop the overthrow and stayed for the most
Bakiyevs failure as a president, but what happenspart neutral?"
now that the opposition has taken over? TheJesse went on to explain; I have no doubt
opposition party that ran out the currentKyrgyzstan's citizens looked unfavorably upon our
administration is poorly organized and ridiculously illinaction towards the former authoritarian regime
prepared to serve the needs of its newof Bakiyev. How could they not? The U.S
constituents. These people haven't even agreeddisplayed clear indifference to the suffering of an
to who will lead their new government much lessentire nation so long as our airbase was
what they will do to correct the failures of theoperational.
past. I find this to be a recurring tragedy of theIndeed, I suppose this criticism is deserved, as we
armed revolution throughout military history.are indifferent lots of places in the world. We can't
People with seemingly pure intentions cannot seebe everything to everyone, and that government
the big picture and simply think removing thewasn't nearly as bad, as some of the African
current regime is all that is required. They fail tonations, or their leaders we have to deal with in
follow through and implement corrective policiesorder to have our bases there, nevertheless
and fall to the same vices. I do not fault thethese are all issue we ought to be considering.